Spooky Cat Pudding Cups November 25, 2016 by Party Pinching For your Spooky Cat Pudding Cups You will need: Peep marshmallow cats Lemon Oreos Leaf sprinkles Pudding cups 1. Place Peep marshmallow cat in pudding cup. 2. Twist off the top of the Oreo. Eat the top unfrosted part. 3. Place the creme half of the cookie behind the cat for the moon. 4. Shake leaf sprinkles on top of pudding.