Great Pumpkin Pudding Cups November 24, 2016 by Party Pinching If you’re a Great Pumpkin believer like I am, then this is the perfect treat for you! So easy to make using store-bought pudding cups, your kids will love to help! You will need: Store-bought chocolate pudding cups Oreos Keebler Classic Sandies Shortbread Cookies Black Edible Marker Pumpkin candy 1. Crush a few Oreos and sprinkle the crumbs on top of the pudding cup. 2. Add a couple of candy pumpkins on top of the pudding cup. 3. Using a black edible marker, draw the outline of Snoopy on the cookie and then color it in. 4. Place cookie in pudding cup.